A Little Choked Up
I say to myself often that I should try to include more positive articles in this blog. Were I more positive about the state of the world, that would be easy, but I am not, so it is not.
But hey, folks, I got one for you today. Reading this article in the WSJ at the end of October made me very happy, even put a tear in my eye. Before I tell you all about it, let me get the negative stuff out of the way. This is a relatively brief report from the WSJ about something they claim is being done at Harvard. Yea, that Harvard. Few facts or figures are given, and the article is not terribly well-written, so I am just going to say: I hope the WSJ is not blowing smoke up my ass and this is all for real.
The article is titled ‘The Brutal Harvard Class That Suddenly Everyone Wants to Take’.
See what I mean about the writing? Everybody? I seriously doubt it, but the enrollment is capped purposely at 90 students, and this year some 180 incoming first-year students applied to enroll. Clearly, 180 applicants is not ‘everybody’. The application to take the course, Humanities 10 (nicknamed ‘Hum 10’) includes a written essay, and the article claims that applications this year were up 40% from the year before. Hence the word ‘suddenly’ in the title. That seems appropriate, a 40% jump in one year is ‘sudden’.
Hum 101 requires a lot of reading, and reading of The Classics. What are The Classics?
Apparently, Jane Austen, Homer, Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations, James Joyce’s Ulysses and other works by Montaigne, Shakespeare, Spinoza, Baldwin, Dante and Plato. (Baldwin means James, I assume.)
Better yet, the seminar – and it is a seminar, in which you better have arrived having read the material – is team taught by six genuine Harvard faculty. Not the grad students and post-doctoral fellows that so many Harvard (and other university) students see at the front of the classroom in their first year. Each faculty member gives two lectures and runs one seminar each term.
I know what you are thinking. Those smart first-year Harvard students are breezing through it all with the help of LLMs to produce digested summaries of all those readings and to write their essays for them, so what is the big deal? Well, according to the article that is not so, and this is a direct quote:
In their applications and in interviews, students expressed the urge to be forced to tackle classics they otherwise wouldn’t read, the need to combat frayed attention spans and the desire for an antidote to The Machine. Several mentioned with disdain that people who aren’t in the class wondered why they didn’t “just Chat the books,” i.e., use AI.
“A lot of what we get out of this class is the human experience, and you can’t get that out of AI,” said Peggy Urdan, a government and neuroscience major from Lexington, Mass. “The only way to get anything out of this class is to not use AI.”
Of course you and I are not there in the class, and to be clear, neither was the WSJ author of this piece. I can only hope that it’s all true.
Like I said, that such a course exists in any university warms my heart. That it is at Harvard is even better, given what else I know about that institution.
Postscript: The comments on this article were almost all highly positive, with some folks saying that Columbia University, also Ivey League, offers something similar only bigger and better. Others wrote to say they had taken a course like this in the past at some university or other. Perhaps that is so, but I never saw anything like it during my 50 combined years as a student and faculty member. Then again, I spent all those years in publicly funded places. Hum 10 required six regular faculty members to show up for a class with only 90 enrolled students. The bean-counters who now run my former employer would laugh – no, sneer – at a proposal to staff anything similar.